Preserving elective surgeries during COVID-19: lesson learnt from 2020
25 January 2021
BLOG POST WRITTEN BY ALEKSANDRA KRYGIEL-NAEL, EMEA ACTING HEAD OF GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS & POLICY FOR MEDICAL DEVICES, J&J, LINKED TO THE EHMA WEBINAR ON ‘PRESERVING ELECTIVE SURGERIES DURING COVID-19‘
The COVID-19 crisis has put a spotlight on health systems and exposed their vulnerabilities. It has brought together stakeholders including governments, academia & researchers, hospitals & healthcare providers and industry to work together on solutions at an unprecedented scale, which we all hope may help save lives and prevent greater human suffering in 2021.
The devastating consequences of this crisis are clearly broad and heavily impact non-COVID patients. Unfortunately, many patients face delayed access to prevention & screening programmes, surgeries, and other treatments. As many have said, ‘the COVID crisis is a marathon, not a sprint’, so we need to draw learnings from 2020 and do our best in ensuring optimal healthcare for all patients in 2021.
Delayed access to surgeries for non-COVID patients
During the initial outbreak of SARS-CoV-2, many European hospitals suspended surgeries and hospital treatments in hope of reducing infection rates and preserving resources for COVID-19 patients.
The postponement of elective surgeries and hospital treatments has resulted in a backlog of procedures with ongoing delays due to the overall diminished capacity of health systems. The current situation is quite diverse in many European countries and regions but all countries face serious challenges to healthcare delivery.
It is important to consider the consequences of such delays in surgeries and treatments. There are concerns that delayed treatment of conditions because of pandemic-related cancellations will lead to deterioration in individual patients’ health, quality of life and ability to work and contribute to society, which at a collective scale may cause substantial societal burden and economic impact. Therefore, catching up the backlog in a safe manner should be seen as an investment in citizen’s health and well-being as well as in the economy, rather than a drain on finances.
On Monday, 18 January 2021, EHMA hosted a webinar on this topic, discussing the lessons learnt from the pandemic from three different country perspectives: the Netherlands, the UK, and Italy. Let’s consider some of the main points raised by the panellists on how treatments and elective surgeries can safely and effectively be preserved or resumed:
Overcoming the most critical moments of the pandemic and preventing further delays:
Effective strategies to anticipate potential delays at the most critical moments of the pandemic are important and should identify early interventions to resume treatments as soon as possible. Among the safest and most effective measures to achieve this, the panellists highlighted:
- Prioritizing vaccination of all HCPs;
- Increasing hygiene measures at hospitals starting with security staff outside, instructing patients to follow protective practices even before entering;
- Separating day-clinic patients from Emergency patients to create “COVID free” or “green zone” hospitals;
- Adjusting shift schemes to manage well-being and account for the mounting strain on health workers;
- Implementing dashboards to help track and anticipate the hospital’s burden to potentially manage the workload and capacity among the broader network of available service centres in the health system.
Managing the backlog
As soon as the most challenging moments of the pandemic are overcome, it is also recommended to plan strategies to manage the backlog of patients whose treatment has been postponed. Sharing of best practice and learnings among hospitals as well as governments is highly encouraged.
Shifting to a data-powered recovery
Further to the exchange of experiences, hospitals and governments could also greatly benefit from the exchange of safe, reliable, and comparable health data. All stakeholders can draw lessons from this crisis to increase the use of patient-reported outcomes and adopt digital services in primary and secondary care, both to support the immediate recovery as well as to inform and enable the transformation of healthcare systems to become more value-based and more resilient for the longer term.
Admittedly, more research and data is needed to assess, understand, and better manage the impacts of the delays in surgeries and treatments. Sharing learnings and best practices can help hospitals prevent and tackle these delays in a safe and effective way for patients, health workers, and health systems. Governments around Europe should already be thinking about recovery plans and strategies to achieve optimal levels of surgical activity in 2021. This will require continuous collaboration among stakeholders. We hope this webinar has served as a relevant step in this direction, providing health managers, healthcare practitioners and policymakers with valuable insights and learnings from the real-world experiences of our panellists to help guide the way forward.
You can watch the recording of the webinar here below:
All the materials and resourses mentioned in the webinar can be found here.
RSV immunisation for infants in Europe: are our health systems ready?
Proposed amendments to the reformed Pharmaceutical Legislation: patient safety and medication shortages
Discover the European Health Management Conference Tracks
What our Members say
I have been active in EHMA since the first years of the '90s and I have seen its evolution from a small association of members interested in sharing knowledge on health management practices to the current status of reference and advisory key player for EU, health systems and organisations, stakeholders associations, industry and universities. EHMA is now a unique knowledge hub, policy advisor, community of practice and network of best in class organisations involved in health policy and management. A place where health managers can build their competences, policy-makers and stakeholder associations envision how to implement and sustain change through health management, industry leaders understand how to engage more effectively with health organisations and systems. The right place to nurture and grow health management capabilities and capacity for every stakeholder of health systems.
Prof. Federico Lega, University of Milan, Italy
Health management has a crucial function in shaping public health and health system challenges. The Medical University of Varna, Bulgaria had success in collaborating with EHMA on EU-funded projects that has resourced us to create new health management competencies for the future workforce. In addition to all classical definitions, health management is a science dealing with individuals, groups, and society at large. It is an art contributing to the beauty of our lives and an interactive communication process at all levels of institutions and human energy. I have also had the pleasure to chair the South Eastern European Special Interest Group which gives members a space to discuss and tools to address how health systems are managed in our regions.
Prof. Todorka Kostadinova, Medical University of Varna, Bulgaria
I enjoy the high level of interaction and engagement in EHMA’s activities, in particular during the annual conference where the panel discussions are rich and well prepared. As a hospital manager and professor of health management, EHMA motivates and inspires me to be creative. You go back home feeling energised from seeing old friends and making new connections, as well as being convinced of serving as EHMA’s ambassador. It’s a strong feeling of interdisciplinary engagement, but it also feels like being part of family-like community.
Prof. Sandra C. Buttigieg, University of Malta, Malta
EHMA is a pre-eminent organisation for everyone working in planning, managing and delivering health services across Europe. As a long standing member of EHMA I have always been impressed by the vibrant community of managers, researchers and academics it has created and by the many opportunities for sharing knowledge and funding opportunities it has brought to its members. Its international scope is impressive and its impact is often felt in management and research across European and national health systems.
Prof. Axel Kaehne, Edge Hill University, UK
Health workforce has become more essential in operating, managing and maintaining health systems lately, particularly in crisis and emergency situations. European healthcare professions and the workforce need to be high on the agenda of managers and decision makers. The Health Services Management Training Centre, Semmelweis University in Hungary is a longstanding EHMA member, because it connects us with collaborators and experts, with whom we can have complex debates, from whom we can learn and at the end find solutions in various challenging fields of healthcare management.
Dr Eszter Kovács, Health Services Management Training Centre, Semmelweis University, Hungary
As a hospital administrator and health management professor, I see on a daily basis that the healthcare challenges require talented and skilled managers to transform it. the EHMA membership has been beneficial to bring healthcare management research and education to the demanding healthcare services world, promoting healthcare management competencies and knowledge creation.
Dr Alexandre Lourenco, APAH - Association of Portuguese Hospital Managers, Portugal
Many healthcare systems in Europe and beyond are facing similar challenges which require innovative and creative solutions. EHMA’s annual conference, webinars, Programme Directors’ group and other activities and resources provide incredible opportunities for networking, connecting and sharing experiences. A distinct feature of EHMA is the diversity of members with representation from many countries, sectors and different communities of practice – academic, policy-makers, practitioners, managers, leaders and students. The annual conference is a highlight in the calendar year, offering a friendly, fun and learningful environment for emerging and established members to engage, collaborate and meet up with old and new friends. I am proud to be a member of the EHMA Board.
Prof. Ann Mahon, University of Manchester, UK
Society evolution, pandemics and ageing modify health needs. So, health policies and services are to change dramatically. EHMA, through webinars, workshops and annual conference provides an excellent insight to a professional changing world, favouring closeness to management innovation and the protagonists of these changes. As a primary care services’ manager, participating in EHMA activities is really worth it and allows to involve oneself in the innovation processes.
Dr Antoni Peris Grao, Consorci Castelldefels Agents de Salut (CASAP), Spain