Putting value at the heart of the procurement process
29 October 2022
Health managers have a key role in acquiring resources, supplies, products and equipment for health and care settings. With a view to contribute to the development and sharing of best practices in procurement, we are engaged in the EcoQUIP+ project that aims to improve healthcare efficiency, quality and environmental sustainability through collaborative innovation procurement. The project directly engages with health managers through a dedicated webinar series exploring innovation procurement’s potential in addressing key healthcare challenges. The webinar ‘Achieving better value in healthcare through strategic procurement‘ is the second episode of the series and looked at how health managers can achieve better value in healthcare by making strategic use of procurement.
The webinar ‘Achieving better value in healthcare through strategic procurement‘ is the second episode of the EcoQUIP+ procurement series for health managers. It featured Prof Dr Louise Knight, Professor Public Sector and Healthcare Procurement at Universiteit Twente, and Ms Caterina Sampol, Coordinator for Public Procurement of Innovation at Hospital de la Santa Creu i Sant Pau to discuss how health managers can achieve better value in healthcare by making strategic use of procurement and how they can incorporate the concept of ‘value’ in their procurement process.
The concept of value
Value refers to how important or useful something is for a given stakeholder. As such, value strongly depends on the context and the needs of the stakeholder. While value-based healthcare consists in shifting from paying for input to paying for outcomes, value-based procurement refers to moving away from lowest price purchasing and seeking short-term cost savings to thinking about long-term efficiency, sustainability, and effectiveness. Value-based procurement requires strategic alignment with suppliers to deliver better outcomes both from an organisational and patients’ perspective.
Value-based procurement in practice – removing resistance
The first step to start the value-based procurement process consists in identifying a problem to solve that has no straightforward solution. The role of procurement experts is to then work closely together with suppliers to explore potential solutions and ensure that internal processes are aligned with new ways of procurement. Key enablers to implement value-based procurement within a given health setting include a good leader, a supportive board of director, the involvement of a multi-disciplinary team and co-creation processes between the supply and demand sides.
A good leader is important as there can be significant resistance to change in the healthcare setting. Having an immediate, high-profile problem within an organisation can decrease some of the resistance. In fact, it can align incentives and create a sense of urgency amongst the team to rethink how current processes are carried out. Starting with an easy-to-solve problem and small successes can create a sense of empowerment and enthusiasm amongst the team, thereby decreasing internal resistance and slowly bringing about the organisational changes required to shift to value-based procurement. Lastly, since procurement requires resources, the leader will also be responsible of bringing on board directors and managers.
Training, education and research – enabling procurer experts
Shifting to value-based procurement in the health sector requires making the process more attractive to young professionals and training senior managers already on the job. Value-based procurement requires a significant skill set, including collaboration and co-creation with suppliers and effective communication with patients to determine what ‘value’ means for them. To learn about value-based procurement, students and working professionals can turn to case studies to learn from others’ wins and failures and get a better understanding of the drivers and barriers of success. Research can also shed light on incentives for implementing value-based procurement and identifying the causes of resistance to change within organisations.
Triggering change towards value-based procurement
The most effective way to trigger change towards value-based procurement in a healthcare setting is to start with a small project that has a big impact. The first step is to appoint a multi-disciplinary team, the procurement support unit (clinicians, patient associations, IT and legal professionals, etc.) who will work together to implement the process. The second step consist in launching an open market consultation to share the identified challenge with industries and evaluate existing solutions. For the third step, the team will collect input from patients to create a set of qualitative key performance indicators (KPIs) and a set of value-indicators. Before signing the contract, it is key that the team agrees on how value will be measured. The fourth step requires setting up an internal plan to successfully implement the contract as well as establishing a governance model, whereby procurers and contractors work together to follow the changes. The key to success is to follow-up on the changes and have a good contract management system in place, by continuously collecting and monitoring the chosen key performance indicators. Lastly, payment models need to be adapted since value-based procurement implies a shift from procuring products to procuring services. The payment might not be steady and linear but might be fluctuating according to the activity. Purchasing services according to value-based principles might not be the cheapest in the short-term but in the medium and long-terms they pay off because value-based procurement produces patient satisfaction and faster, better recovery processes.
Implementing value-based procurement within a healthcare setting is not easy but is worth it. The most important step is to make a start. Value-based procurement is also not an option, but a must. In fact, in cases of limited resources, price-based procurement does not yield the best outcomes, particularly not in the health care sector. Budget constraints require innovative approaches and value-based procurement is one of the innovative solutions to turn to.
The EcoQUIP+ project is co-funded by the COSME programme of the European Union under Grant Agreement number 857790. This page and the publications contained herein only reflects the author’s views. The European Union is not liable for any use that might be made of the information contained in this page and publications.
Unlocking the potential of health data: the role of hospital pharmacies in the European Health Data Space Regulation
Unlocking the potential of health data: the role of hospital pharmacies in the European Health Data Space Regulation
4 July 2023
The European Commission clarified that hospital pharmacies are covered in the European Health Data Space Regulation, ensuring continuity of care for patients accessing treatment across borders.
UNIVANTS of Healthcare Excellence Awards: Celebrating the 2022 winners
Stakeholder involvement for more transparent and inclusive health technology assessment
What our Members say
I have been active in EHMA since the first years of the '90s and I have seen its evolution from a small association of members interested in sharing knowledge on health management practices to the current status of reference and advisory key player for EU, health systems and organisations, stakeholders associations, industry and universities. EHMA is now a unique knowledge hub, policy advisor, community of practice and network of best in class organisations involved in health policy and management. A place where health managers can build their competences, policy-makers and stakeholder associations envision how to implement and sustain change through health management, industry leaders understand how to engage more effectively with health organisations and systems. The right place to nurture and grow health management capabilities and capacity for every stakeholder of health systems.
Prof. Federico Lega, University of Milan, Italy
Health management has a crucial function in shaping public health and health system challenges. The Medical University of Varna, Bulgaria had success in collaborating with EHMA on EU-funded projects that has resourced us to create new health management competencies for the future workforce. In addition to all classical definitions, health management is a science dealing with individuals, groups, and society at large. It is an art contributing to the beauty of our lives and an interactive communication process at all levels of institutions and human energy. I have also had the pleasure to chair the South Eastern European Special Interest Group which gives members a space to discuss and tools to address how health systems are managed in our regions.
Prof. Todorka Kostadinova, Medical University of Varna, Bulgaria
I enjoy the high level of interaction and engagement in EHMA’s activities, in particular during the annual conference where the panel discussions are rich and well prepared. As a hospital manager and professor of health management, EHMA motivates and inspires me to be creative. You go back home feeling energised from seeing old friends and making new connections, as well as being convinced of serving as EHMA’s ambassador. It’s a strong feeling of interdisciplinary engagement, but it also feels like being part of family-like community.
Prof. Sandra C. Buttigieg, University of Malta, Malta
EHMA is a pre-eminent organisation for everyone working in planning, managing and delivering health services across Europe. As a long standing member of EHMA I have always been impressed by the vibrant community of managers, researchers and academics it has created and by the many opportunities for sharing knowledge and funding opportunities it has brought to its members. Its international scope is impressive and its impact is often felt in management and research across European and national health systems.
Prof. Axel Kaehne, Edge Hill University, UK
Health workforce has become more essential in operating, managing and maintaining health systems lately, particularly in crisis and emergency situations. European healthcare professions and the workforce need to be high on the agenda of managers and decision makers. The Health Services Management Training Centre, Semmelweis University in Hungary is a longstanding EHMA member, because it connects us with collaborators and experts, with whom we can have complex debates, from whom we can learn and at the end find solutions in various challenging fields of healthcare management.
Dr Eszter Kovács, Health Services Management Training Centre, Semmelweis University, Hungary
As a hospital administrator and health management professor, I see on a daily basis that the healthcare challenges require talented and skilled managers to transform it. the EHMA membership has been beneficial to bring healthcare management research and education to the demanding healthcare services world, promoting healthcare management competencies and knowledge creation.
Dr Alexandre Lourenco, APAH - Association of Portuguese Hospital Managers, Portugal
Many healthcare systems in Europe and beyond are facing similar challenges which require innovative and creative solutions. EHMA’s annual conference, webinars, Programme Directors’ group and other activities and resources provide incredible opportunities for networking, connecting and sharing experiences. A distinct feature of EHMA is the diversity of members with representation from many countries, sectors and different communities of practice – academic, policy-makers, practitioners, managers, leaders and students. The annual conference is a highlight in the calendar year, offering a friendly, fun and learningful environment for emerging and established members to engage, collaborate and meet up with old and new friends. I am proud to be a member of the EHMA Board.
Prof. Ann Mahon, University of Manchester, UK
Society evolution, pandemics and ageing modify health needs. So, health policies and services are to change dramatically. EHMA, through webinars, workshops and annual conference provides an excellent insight to a professional changing world, favouring closeness to management innovation and the protagonists of these changes. As a primary care services’ manager, participating in EHMA activities is really worth it and allows to involve oneself in the innovation processes.
Dr Antoni Peris Grao, Consorci Castelldefels Agents de Salut (CASAP), Spain